My neighbor claims a prescriptive easement over my land. How do I challenge it in CA?

What the Law Says

Under California law, a prescriptive easement arises when someone uses another’s land openly, notoriously, continuously, adversely (without permission), and exclusively for five years (Cal. Civ. Code § 813; see also Gion v. City of Santa Cruz (1970) 2 Cal.3d 29). Unlike adverse possession, a prescriptive easement does not require intent to claim ownership—only a hostile use inconsistent with the owner’s rights. Critically, the use must be 'adverse'—meaning without express or implied consent; any evidence of permission (e.g., verbal agreement, written license, or acquiescence) defeats the claim. The burden of proof rests entirely on the claimant to establish all elements by clear and convincing evidence (Hansen v. Richey (1994) 26 Cal.App.4th 1781).

Practical Steps

First, gather contemporaneous evidence showing permissive use (e.g., text messages, emails, prior written agreements, witness statements, or maintenance records indicating your consent or objection). Next, consult a California real property attorney to assess whether the neighbor’s use satisfies all five legal elements—and whether tolling or estoppel applies (e.g., if you were out of state or incapacitated during part of the period). If litigation is unavoidable, file a quiet title action (Code Civ. Proc. § 760.020) in the county superior court where the land lies, seeking declaratory relief that no prescriptive easement exists. Do not delay: while the prescriptive period itself is five years, failure to act may strengthen the neighbor’s claim through continued use and potential laches arguments.

Sources