Can I claim for emotional or psychological injury without physical harm?

How the answer differs across 7 jurisdictions

The Short Answer

Yes, you can claim damages for mental distress or PTSD without a physical injury in Canada, but you must prove the mental injury is serious, prolonged, and rises above ordinary emotional upset.

No physical inj
Legal threshold
Serious & prolo
Injury standard
Expert evidence
Evidence rule
Ordinary fortit
Foreseeability
The Short Answer

Yes, you can claim for psychological injury without physical harm in Ireland, but only if you meet strict legal criteria — such as being a 'primary victim' or having a close familial relationship with the injured person and witnessing the event.

No standalone c
Psychological injury rule
Primary victim
Eligibility condition
1961 Act
Governing law
Witness require
Secondary victim test
The Short Answer

Yes, you may be able to claim for psychiatric injury as a secondary victim if you meet strict legal criteria — including close ties to the primary victim and proximity to the event in time and space.

3 years
Limitation period
Close tie
Relationship test
Sudden shock
Perception requirement
Proximity
Time & space test
The Short Answer

Yes, you can claim for mental anguish without physical injury in India, but only in limited situations — such as defamation, breach of constitutional rights, or intentional infliction of emotional distress — and courts generally require proof of severe, proven psychological harm.

No standalone t
Legal status
Defamation Act
Key law
Article 21
Constitutional basis
Severe distress
Required proof
South KoreaFull article
The Short Answer

No, under South Korean law, you generally cannot claim damages for emotional distress alone without accompanying physical injury, property damage, or violation of a legally protected right.

No standalone
Emotional distress
Art. 751
Civil Act
Requires harm
Legal condition
3 years
Limitation period
US-CaliforniaFull article
The Short Answer

Yes, in California you can recover damages for emotional distress without physical injury in certain situations — such as intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED), negligent infliction of emotional distress (NIED) under limited circumstances, or when tied to a statutory violation.

No physical inj
Intentional claims
Bystander NIED:
Proximity rule
3 years
IIED statute of limitations
2 years
NIED statute of limitations
US-New YorkFull article
The Short Answer

In New York, the 'zone of danger' rule requires a plaintiff to have been in immediate physical danger from the defendant’s negligent conduct to recover for negligent infliction of emotional distress (NIED).

Physical peril
Required element
No bystander ru
NY rejects recovery for mere witnesses
1966 origin
Rule established in Battalla
Direct exposure
Must be in danger zone

Read Full Articles

Not legal advice. This article is general information based on publicly available sources, written for educational purposes. Laws change and individual situations vary. Consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction before acting on anything you read here. Last reviewed: June 2026.