An EU manufacturer refuses my warranty claim. What small claims options exist?

What the Law Says

Under Directive 1999/44/EC (as amended and transposed into national law), consumers in the EU have mandatory statutory rights against sellers — not just manufacturers — for lack of conformity in goods, including defects appearing within two years of delivery. While the manufacturer is not directly liable under this directive unless it acts as the seller or offers an extended commercial warranty, national laws may impose supplementary obligations (e.g., German Product Liability Act §1, or French Consumer Code Art. L. 211-4). For cross-border disputes with an EU-based manufacturer, Regulation (EC) No 861/2007 establishes the European Small Claims Procedure (ESCP), applicable to civil and commercial matters up to €5,000. The ESCP provides a written, largely paperless, and expedited process with strict deadlines (e.g., 30-day response period for the defendant) and enforceable judgments across all EU Member States (except Denmark).

Practical Steps

First, send a formal written complaint to the manufacturer citing Directive 1999/44/EC and your national transposition law (e.g., UK Consumer Rights Act 2015, German BGB §437, or French Code de la consommation Art. L. 217-4), specifying your remedy request (repair, replacement, refund) and setting a reasonable deadline (e.g., 14 days). If unresolved and the claim is ≤€5,000, file Form A (Small Claims Application) with the competent court in your Member State of residence — or in the manufacturer’s Member State — using the ESCP. Courts must accept electronic filing (per Regulation (EU) 2015/2422), and no lawyer is required. You may seek free assistance from your national European Consumer Centre (ECC-Net), which can mediate or advise on jurisdiction and evidence (e.g., proof of purchase, defect documentation, prior correspondence). Judgments issued under ESCP are automatically recognised and enforceable in other EU countries without exequatur.

Sources